Wednesday, August 18, 2021

#IndianDataDollar: A whitepaper (Version 1.0: Fourth Page)

 Contd from Page 3....

Not just three generations of blockchains have simultaneously grown as a collective wave rather they have also grown laterally with rise of interesting tools and industries like Decentralized Finance (Defi), Non-Fungible Tokens (NFTs) and Layer II scaling solutions like Polygon, Lightning Network, ZK Roll-ups and so on. Though there is no exact proof, it is estimated that there are around 200 million users already on-boarded to this ecosystem and more than 10 million transactions are happening daily as of now (August 2021).

These are largely censorship resistant systems that are nearly impossible to ban by even powerful regulators. Even if they prohibit their use, it will only drive crypto currencies underground but not kill them. The foundational logic behind this is that they are planetary infrastructure used by peer-to-peer actors. They are completely parallel to KYC-led banking networks and other regulated financial activities. In this scenario, how to regulate crypto currencies is a big headache for governments. If their use rises underground, it will result in loss of taxation as well as compliance culture. If they are to be regulated, it will require massive global cooperation of scale as big as creating a new global parliament. It seems a non-possibility looking at the splintering of global opinion in matters of origin of covid-19, eradication of poverty, human migration resulting from global warming or regulating big tech and many such issues. What options does a developing country like India have in this kind of a historical setting? If it does not allow crypto currencies, it kills the huge wave of innovation thriving in the brilliant entrepreneurs of India. If it allows them without restrictions, how to stop the spill over of black money operators using crypto currencies? If it does not build a credible regulatory framework, its large corporate class and citizens will never know how to leapfrog with this new wave of wealth-building.

1.1  The difficult economic outlook for a post-pandemic India

The universal shutdown due to Covid-19 has hit Indian economy harder than many countries. As per Centre for Monitoring Indian Economy (CMIE) report, India lost 114 million jobs in April, 2020. Though the situation improved in the second half of the year, it is still not rosy enough. India’s pre-covid employment number was 404 million workers. In May, 2021, this number had declined to 375.5 million which means loss of 28.5 m jobs. The overall state of Indian economy showed a shrinkage of 7.3% in the year 2020-21 and even the hopeful rebound in 2021-22 was downgraded from 12.5% to 9.5% by the IMF. Though the Indian government has done its bit to control the problem, it is more damage control rather than pulling the economy out of a trap. It seems that these two financial years 20-21 and 21-22 would end up with a GDP that would be lesser than it was in 2019. For a developing economy that was already slowing, this is a double whammy. Though some sectors have bounced back yet the broader economy is having K-shaped recovery. ..........................................Pandemic has paralyzed all territorial units of productivity and income for nation-states, enterprises and individuals. If virus is a singularity attack, political regimes need a singularity defence. Radical monetary imagination alone can stop the second order effects of this pandemic.

3.0 Time to make out-of-the-box choices

............................... Whether the threat comes from outside in the form of Chinese CBDC, Facebook’s monetary network, China-US enmity or crypto currencies or it comes from inside in the form of economic decline, we cannot stick to old methods for facing these challenges. Our statesmanship is stuck with a model of a territorial state for the last seven decades whereas the world today is equally virtual also.


No comments: